Gallagher: Schneider gives exclusive interview about Jays not tendering him
The Toronto Blue Jays non-tendered Davis Schneider on Friday.
November 21, 2026
By Danny Gallagher
Canadian Baseball Network
Davis Schneider was on his way from his hometown of Berlin, N.J. to Philadelphia International Airport on Friday afternoon to pick up family members returning from a vacation in Aruba when he got a phone call.
Calling was Blue Jays general manager Ross Atkins, who gave him the sad news the club wasn't tendering the fan favourite and long-time company man a contract for the 2027 season, meaning he was a free agent.
It was Schneider's first crack as an arbitration-eligible player, a Super 2 guy, and was projected to earn an inexpensive $1.3-million U.S. next season. After too many trips to triple-A Buffalo, he had exhausted all of his minor-league options.
"I was kind of expecting it,'' Schneider said in an exclusive interview about the negative news. "I knew it might happen. It's part of the business. It's part of the game. I'm not going to grind about it too much. It's one of those things. Life goes on. Ross was professional about it. He called me just before the deadline (5 p.m. E.T.). He's a really good person.''
Schneider spent most of his time with the Blue Jays in the majors as an utility player at second base or in left field. He was a 28th-round draft pick who came out of nowhere and gained a cult following with his unsung-hero persona, moustache and constant adjusting of his glasses in between pitches after he made an historic debut with a home run in first major league at bat against James Paxton (Ladner, B.C.) of the Red Sox at Fenway Park on Aug. 4, 2023. He went 9-for-13 in that series. It was the stuff of legends and he finished the season with a solid .276 average, eight homers and 20 RBIs.
Then, his offence started to fall apart. This past season, he hit .145 in 69 games. Major-league pitching had caught up to him. The Jays decided not to go in favour of a popular player and rather went with Josh Smith, who provides more upside, more offence and can play second base and left field like Schneider. The team gave Schneider many chances over the course of four seasons
"I could have adjusted better the last two years,'' Schneider said. "I should have hit more. The pitchers were able to find my weaknesses. I didn't want to go after pitches I can't hit and get me in trouble. I'm just going to work out and get better.''
Schneider won't forget that dinger off Paxton and the no-doubter lead-off home run off Blake Snell of the Dodgers in Game 5 of the 2025 World Series at Dodger Stadium. He remembers being nervous before his first game.
“I was interviewed and then I saw all the guys on the team cheering and being happy for me,'' he said.
As for that home off Snell, he said, "He was healthy enough to start and I was excited. I was going to swing at the first pitch, no matter what. I didn't hit it too hard but it got out of the park. We came so close to winning the World Series. It was pretty special and memorable. Coming in on the other side sucks but I have great memories of that season. We almost won the whole thing.''
Schneider will miss guys like Addison Barger and his good friend Ernie Clement and all the fans.
"I spent 9½ years with the organization and made a lot of friends,'' he said. "They were good friends more than teammates. (Hitting coach) David Popkins is one of the best in the business in the league. He's one of my really good friends. I was lucky to be with the organization that long. Toronto is one of the greatest cities I could play for, in the whole country, in all of North America. It's such a great fan base that wants you to succeed. The Toronto fans are the best in the world.''
As for the future, Schneider was asked if the Phillies, close to his home in New Jersey, would be a great team to sign with, he said, "I'd love to play for them. Whatever is the best opportunity. We'll see what happens.''